I wish they would arrest you for the way you stole my heart
But Im the one whos doing time now that were apart
You came to me with a heart that true
And said I could believe in you
But then you changed your line, you see
And tried to put these chains on me
You think hearts are made for breaking
And love is for the taking
But though its wrong to be with you
I come back every time, oh baby
I cant help myself returning to the scene of the crime
There should be a law that says lying is a crime
The nights you said you loved me, were you just making time?
I cant help the way I feel
The love inside for you is real
If only I could make you see
Im not the girl you want me to be
You think hearts are made for breaking
And love is for the taking
But though its wrong to be with you
I come back every time, oh baby
I cant help myself returning to the scene of the crime
Theres a storm outside, the lights are gone and Im alone
I close my eyes and see your face, reach for the phone
Remember how it used to be when we were each others destiny?
My head says I should let you go
But my heart will never just say no
You think hearts are made for breaking
And love is for the taking
But though its wrong to be with you
I come back every time, oh baby
I cant help myself returning to the scene of the crime
I cant help myself returning to the scene of the crime