Like April snow blowin around in Gramercy Park
The two of us were never meant to last
You left your traces and drove away like a circus in town
A three-ring show that comes and goes too fast
The best of friends have been divided by a kiss
And if we can't love again, I can always reminisce
Cinderella beautiful, this one is for you
We almost made our fairy tale come true
And happy ever after was unavailable
Now two years after midnight
I'm still thinking of those yesterdays
When I was prince charming
And you were Cinderella beautiful
You know I don't like Christmas but thanks for the holiday card
I didn't know you moved so far away
The winter months were the usual mess back here in New York
Every day another shade of gray
I'm doing fine but sometimes, every now and then
I miss who I was with you and I wonder where he went
Cinderella beautiful, this one is for you
We almost made our fairy tale come true, oh
And happy ever after was unavailable
Now two years after midnight
I'm still thinking of those yesterdays
When I was prince charming
And you were Cinderella beautiful
And I know our time has come and gone away
So why do I waste my nights
Dreaming of a you and me that can never be again?
Oh, and happy ever after was unavailable
Now two years after midnight
Im still thinking of those yesterdays
When I was prince charming
And you were Cinderella beautiful
Cinderella beautiful, oh Cinderella beautiful